Giving thanks:  Dr. Joseph Roberts, professor of preaching at Columbia Seminary, speaks to the congregation at First Presbyterian Church. The combined choir performed on Tuesday night as part of the church’s annual Thanksgiving celebration and included singers from Bethabara Missionary Baptist Church; Bethlehem Baptist Church; Church of the Good Shepherd, Episcopal; First Baptist Church; First United Methodist Church; First Presbyterian Church; Grace United Methodist Church; and St. Paul A.M.E. Church.